The Overlooked Readers: How Traditional Publishing Has Marginalised Men
In a recent blog by the trash site Dazed, it’s been suggested that straight men are increasingly disengaged from reading novels. The truth is the complete opposite. Men do read, and they read a lot. It’s just that traditional publishers have abandoned males in favour of pursuing female readers.
A closer look at the dynamics of the publishing industry reveals a nuanced picture: traditional publishers have increasingly catered to women and feminist themes, sidelining content that might appeal to male readers. Whether this is down to ‘wokeness’ or a deliberate anti-male movement is up for debate but one thing is clear this shift has led to a notable migration of male readers towards the indie book publishing sphere, where diverse and engaging fiction tailored to their interests is flourishing.
The Shift in Traditional Publishing
The contemporary publishing landscape has seen a marked focus on themes and narratives that resonate with female readers. Publishers have targeted this demographic, recognising the substantial market potential. The likes of romantasy series like Twilight etc went on to make billions so it’s understandable. Consequently, novels featuring strong female protagonists, feminist themes, and narratives exploring women's experiences have dominated bestseller lists and literary awards.
While this focus is commendable in many ways, it inadvertently creates a gap for male readers seeking content that reflects their experiences and interests.
As publishers chase the lucrative female market, the breadth of fiction catering to men has diminished, leaving many feeling alienated. When one side constantly whined that they had no representation and then promptly excludes others it’s a tad hypocritical.
Bookstores and Gender Bias
Walk into any major bookstore, and the bias towards female readers becomes evident. Prominent displays often feature romantasy novels, contemporary romance, and women's fiction, genres that predominantly appeal to women. These books are given prime real estate near the entrances and in eye-catching displays. In contrast, fiction that might interest male readers, such as thrillers, science fiction, and adventure novels, is often relegated to the back corners or lower shelves. This layout not only reflects the industry’s focus but also reinforces the perception that fiction is primarily for women.
The Rise of Indie Publishing
In response to this shift, many male readers have turned to indie publishing for their literary fix. Independent authors and small presses, unburdened by the commercial pressures of mainstream publishing, have seized the opportunity to fill this void. They offer a diverse range of genres and themes that resonate with male readers, from action-packed thrillers, dark fantasy and science fiction.
Indie authors have the freedom to experiment and address topics often overlooked by traditional publishers. This creative liberty has resulted in a vibrant and varied indie fiction landscape that appeals to many men. Platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing and Smashwords have democratized access to publishing, enabling a plethora of voices to reach a global audience without gatekeeping by traditional publishers.
Men Do Read Fiction
Contrary to the stereotype that men are disinterested in fiction, evidence shows that men do read a significant amount of literature – just not the types that dominate mainstream bookshops and literary discussions. Genres such as fantasy, science fiction, historical fiction, and even romance (when written from a male perspective) have large male readerships. The issue lies not in men’s aversion to reading but in the availability of material that captivates their interests.
The notion that straight men are disengaged from reading novels is a misrepresentation of a more complex reality. Traditional publishing's pursuit of female and feminist narratives, while valuable, has neglected the interests of male readers, pushing them towards the thriving indie book market. It’s here that they find stories that speak to their experiences, interests, and imaginations, proving that men are indeed avid readers when offered the right content.
It’s time for traditional publishers to recognize this disparity and strive for a more inclusive approach that celebrates and caters to all readers, ensuring that everyone can find a story that speaks to them. Until trad publishers realise this, men can continue to get their book fix from the wealth of fantastic indie authors who are writing the stories they want to read.
***
If you enjoyed this article and want to support more content like this, consider becoming a Patreon subscriber. Your support helps us continue to explore and highlight important issues in the publishing industry, give indie authors a voice and deliver reviews.
